Thursday, February 10, 2011
Twins Open To Trading Liriano
But as time passed following my reading that article, I settled down. Especially after reading Seth Stohs tweet, it sank in. The Twins aren't trading Frankie without getting a great deal in return. Liriano still has a couple of seasons left under team control before he can enter free agency. And right now his value his very high coming off the season he had. And the Twins unwillingness to sign him long term this offseason could show they are looking into it. But it could also say they want to see another year like 2010 first before giving him a long term contract, so he can prove the injury is behind him.
For those of you who say, "Look how the Johan Santana trade ended up," I have to disagree with you, when it comes to trading Liriano. For one, in the offseason between 2007 and 2008, the Twins really had no choice but to trade Santana. He was about to enter the final year of his contract. The Twins did not want to lose him without getting anything in return, via free agency (They would of gotten a couple of compensation draft choices had he walked). And they obviously weren't going to be able to resign him. He was, at that point, the best pitcher in the game. So their desperation to trade him kicked in. And they ended up getting a deal for less than what they should of gotten in return. They recieved OF Carlos Gomez, RHP Phillip Humber, RHP Kevin Mulvey, and RHP Deolis Guerra (All pitchers were starters). All but Guerra are no longer in the Twins system. And it is my opinion that either team got the better of the deal. Santana has been stellar for the Mets, but injuries have derailed his last two seasons and the team has gotten progressively worse since his arrival.
My point with tying Santana and Liriano is the Twins don't have that desperation to trade him right now. If anyone is desperate, it will be the team trading for Liriano. So if he does get traded, the Twins should receive a much better package in return. And i'll admit, its hard to talk about this when less phenomenal pitchers like Scott Baker and Nick Blackburn recieved long term extensions. So for now, we just have to relax about this. And who knows, with a lot of big contracts (Cuddyer, Nathan, Capps) coming off the books, the Twins could very well lock up Liriano. We'll just have to wait and see.
Tuesday, February 8, 2011
Michael Young...A Twin?
But lets think about this. Would Twins GM Bill Smith pull the trigger on a trade that brings Michael Young to Twins Territory? One could make the case that they can and that they should. Since his arrival in the Major Leagues in 2001, Young has been one of the best contact hitters in baseball. He carries a .300 career average. He won the AL batting title in 2005, hitting .331 while hammering 221 hits. He was named to the All Star game 6 straight years (2004-09), and in 2006 he was named All Star Game MVP after hitting a two strike, two out, two RBI triple off of Trevor Hoffman in the ninth inning to give the AL a 3-2 lead. He has been the face of the Rangers since Alex Rodriguez's departure following the 2003 season. And Texas finally got to the World Series in 2010. He has been one of the most significant players in their history. But it all hasn't been raining gold for Young in his time there. The Rangers were simply one of the worst teams in baseball up until 2008, when their young talent finally came around. And during Young's time in Texas he has grudgingly changed positions from second base to short stop to third base up until now when he was slated to share time as a DH. hard to believe that Texas would pay him $16 million to SHARE time as the DH.
The Twins could use Michael Young up the middle for 2011. But it would appear that the Twins are committed to Tsuyoshi Nishioka and Alexi Casilla as their second base/short stop combo. The team was looking to add more speed at those positions as they parted ways with Orlando Hudson and J.J. Hardy who do not possess great speed. But if Texas came calling with a good deal would the Twins really say no to upgrading their middle infield? Young does not possess good speed. But he would fill in nicely in the second spot in the batting order behind Denard Span and ahead of Joe Mauer, due to his good batting average over the years.
Texas could use a decent backup infielder, so I could see Alexi Casilla as part of such deal. In my head a deal would probably send Young and cash to the Twins and either Casilla and two prospects or Casilla and either Scott Baker, Nick Blackburn, or Kevin Slowey (And maybe a prospect) to Texas. The Rangers will almost certainly have to eat a large sum of Young's salary regardless of who he gets dealt to due to the timing of this trade. And in the Twins case it might need to be a larger sum due to the fact the payroll has certainly reached its cap as it will hit $115 million come opening day. And to me that is the make or break part of the deal.
But does Bill Smith even want to make this trade? It is very unlikely that he will. As before mentioned Colorado is the front runners for Young. And it is not even a given that the Rangers want to trade Young. But if there is some common ground between the Twins and Rangers, would Smith give an honest effort to bring Young here? I would sure hope so. Because he is going into Spring Training with two unproven players up the middle on a team that is expected to defend its back to back AL Central titles. And that does not give me a good feeling.
Monday, February 7, 2011
Summing up the Twins Offseason
"If you proceed under the assumption that the Twins have the most talent in the division and had the least work to do this winter, they fared OK. They brought back Carl Pavano for a guaranteed two years and $16.5 million -- a reasonable investment for a guy who pitched 217 innings. They also fended off a challenge from the Texas Rangers to re-sign Jim Thome. He's beloved in the clubhouse, and will help sell a few tickets and generate some feel-good vibes on his journey from 589 to 600 home runs.
There's some upheaval up the middle, where the double-play combination of Orlando Hudson and J.J. Hardy gives way to Alexi Casilla at shortstop and Tsuyoshi Nishioka at second base. Or will Nishioka play short with Casilla at second? That question will play out in spring training in Florida.
Joe Nathan's return as closer will help enormously, and Matt Capps is a capable setup man. But Minnesota's relief contingent ranked fourth in the league with a 3.49 ERA, and the bullpen took a hit with the departure of Guerrier, Crain, Rauch and Fuentes.
Finally, the Twins go to spring training with first baseman Justin Morneau's concussion issues lingering over the team. Michael Cuddyer is available to shift to first and Jason Kubel can slot into right field. But how much does manager Ron Gardenhire want to be leaning a lot on a 40-year-old Thome at DH?"
Crasnick went on to give the Twins offseason grade a C. But I think that is too generous of a grade for Bill Smith. You may recall that at the end of last season I blogged about some team needs for 2011. I said that the Twins need to bring in a power arm (starter or reliever) and a right handed power bat because they fall victim to the Yankees left handed starters come October. Two things they did not do a good job of acquiring.
Yes, Jim Hoey (acquired in the J.J. Hardy trade) is projected to be a power arm. But I was hoping for a more proven power arm out of the bullpen. And the Twins will rely on Michael Cuddyer and Delmon Young as their right handed power bats. I can see the case for Delmon Young who is coming off a great 2010. But Cuddyer's power numbers dropped off significantly from 2009 to 2010. And his $10.5 million salary for 2011 probably prevented the Twins from adding another significant right handed bat. So I can't consider him to be a decent right handed bat for 2011.
And as for that bullpen, the Twins now have more needs than they left us in 2010. Matt Guerrier, Jesse Crain, Jon Rauch, and Brian Fuentes all left via free agency. And replacing them will be Hoey, Scott Diamond (Rule 5 draft pick), Eric Hacker (Free agent signee), and Anthony Slama. All bring serious question marks into 2011. And don't forget Joe Nathan returns from Tommy John surgery and his effectiveness is questionable.
So if I had to grade the Twins offseason, they would get a 'D'. They did not add a decent arm to the bullpen, they let them all leave. And they did not add that right handed power bat I felt they needed. Their "big move" was signing Japanese star Tsuyoshi Nishioka to play up the middle. He has serious question marks too. And if you look at what the Tigers and White Sox did, the Twins have serious work cut out for them. The White Sox moves now puts them in a big position to not only be Central favorites, but AL favorites. But the past two years, Bill Smith has made some effective moves mid season to help the club down the stretch. Lets hope he can do that again. And hope for a minor miracle from the bullpen...or else its going to be a long year.
Football is Over...
Sunday, January 30, 2011
Twins Fest, Cuddyer, Trees, and the countdown
Cuddyer, 32 in March, is entering the final season of his contract and he could very well be playing for a new team come 2012. Cuddy had a down year in 2010 hitting .271 with 14 HR and 81 RBI. At season's end it was revealed that Cuddy needed surgery on his right knee and that he battled through the injury most of the season. And this was coming off a '09 season where he filled in for Justin Morneau down the stretch, hitting 32 HR and driving in 94 runs.
Michael has often been praised highly by his manager Ron Gardenhire for his effort and leadership. Gardy has referred to Cuddyer as the team MVP on a few occasions. You can make the argument for that. Despite having up and down seasons, Cuddyer is a valuable part of the Twins. You can't deny it. And I would love to see him play his whole career as a Twin. But another average year from Cuddy in 2011 will almost certainly end his tenure in Twins pinstripes. So Cuddy will be an interesting case to watch in 2011.
(*) As before mentioned Twins Fest was held at the National Sports Center in Blaine. The Twins used the Sports Hall as the main building, and the Schwan Center for the big autograph stations. I personally did not like this place. The sports hall felt cramped. Trying to go up and down the rows of collectable sellers was ridiculous. And when going out to the Schwan Center to get Cuddyer's autograph, we were forced to wait outdoors for this due to the amount of people already in the building. The Twins should of given a warning that you might have to wait outside. So hopefully, this can return to the Metrodome next year.
(*) Yesterday the Twins announced that they will be relocating the spruce trees that were located above the center field wall. According to Michael Cuddyer in this article, he was scared that he would no longer be able to see the ball due to the shadows the trees cast. So my question here is: Why wasn't this looked into more? And if this was that bad, why wasn't this taken care of during the year? I guess this was one aspect of Target Field the Twins did very little research on. Also, the backdrop will be painted a darker color to help see the ball from the batters box more clearly. So maybe we will see some more home team home runs at Target Field in 2011.
(*) There are 18 days until pitchers and catchers report (February 16), 61 days until Opening Day @ Toronto (April 1), and 68 days until the home opener vs Oakland (April 8)!
Thursday, January 20, 2011
Pavano Returns; Surplus of Starters
Now that Pavano has returned, the Twins starting rotation now consists of Francisco Liriano, Pavano, Scott Baker, Brian Duensing, Kevin Slowey, and Nick Blackburn. And for those counting, that is six starters when a typical rotation consists of five. So now the Twins have a surplus of starters and they still have a few holes in their roster. The solution I would like to offer is simple: Trade one. But the question is, which one do you part with?
Given how well Liriano pitched last year, he will stay. Brian Duensing was pretty valuable after he went into the rotation, so he will stay too. And Nick Blackburn was locked into a long term deal last offseason, so I wouldn't think anyone would want to take on his contract. So that leaves Baker and Slowey as the two viable trade candidates.
There are a few turnoffs when looking at trading for Scott Baker. Only once in his four big league seasons has he turned in a sub 4 ERA. He has been very inconsistent during his time in the big leagues. Although each of the past three seasons he has pitched at least 170 innings. So he can be a valuable innings eater. But the big turnoff is his remaining contract for 2011 through 2013. His salary will be $5 million in 2011, $6.5 million in 2012, and 2013 there is a $9.25 million team option. So clearly if trying to trade Scott Baker, the team needs to have payroll flexibility. And by this point in the offseason, many teams have spent their money already. So the options are limited for trading Baker.
Kevin Slowey doesn't have Scott Baker's big contract. So there is a big plus for trying to trade him. Slowey was one of three Twins to file arbitration numbers on Tuesday. So he will make somewhere between $2-$3 million in 2011. Slowey is known as a control artist. So when he is on, he can really paint the corners. But in 2009, he had wrist surgery on his pitching hand. So in 2010 we saw him try and come back from that. He too was like Baker, very inconsistent. But that can be blamed on the wrist injury. He has played three full big league seasons and he has yet to go beyond 160 innings in a season. But again, that is due to the wrist. But because of his lower salary, the Twins should have better options moving him.
So despite the wrist injury, Slowey is the more valuable pitcher to trade here. I'd rather trade Baker and give Slowey the shot. But Baker's contract really handcuffs the options of where he could go. Some people could say that we should hold on to the six starters and just have one start at AAA and go from there. But with Kyle Gibson making his rapid ascent to AAA last year, I would like to see him get a call up in 2011 if needed. The Twins really need bullpen help. That's why they need to trade one of these starters, so they can at least get one solid reliever in return. Maybe acquire a middle infielder prospect too since the depth there took a hit this offseason. So hopefully the right move can be made with this surplus of starters. Because the Twins really need a move here...
Sunday, January 16, 2011
Twins Bring Back Thome
But from a roster standpoint, I have to disagree with this move. Don't get me wrong, I love Jim Thome. He is a Hall of Fame player both on the field and off the field. And it was fun watching him tee off on opposing pitchers. But when push comes to shove, the Twins have so many left handed bats in their lineup. And when facing an effective lefty starter, the lineup is very vunerable. And bringing back a guy who is a career .238 hitter against lefties, on a very limited budget is a bad move. The Twins desperately need a right handed power bat who can hit off the bench and DH when lefties are starting.
With legitimate right handed 1B/DH players out there (Jorge Cantu, Troy Glaus), it made no sense to have Thome return when he is purely a DH. He just can't get around quick enough to field anymore. And as stated before, the Twins have a limited budget during the offseason and limited roster spots to fill. The bench already consists of Drew Butera (C), Jason Repko (OF), and Matt Tolbert(INF). And that left only one spot to fill (Unless Gardy goes with 11 pitchers, but that is highly unlikely given the state of the bullpen), which was now given to Thome. The Twins need a viable option at first if Justin Morneau suffers concussion symptoms again during the year. And Michael Cuddyer is not that option. He just didn't stand out defensively at first. Many balls in the dirt that a regular first baseman should be scooped up, didn't get scooped up. And it became very noticeable. And of the before mention players on the bench, Tolbert and Thome are the only ones who could fill in at first. So unless Thome decides he wants to give fielding another try, the Twins are going with Morneau at first and Cuddyer as his back up.
Thome had a great 2010 season (The best moment was his walk off against the White Sox). But it is very unlikely he can repeat what he did in 2010 for 2011. His age just doesn't say he can repeat those numbers. And I hope people realize that so they won't be letdown. And I was kind of hoping the Twins would realize that and let Thome move on so they could make this ballclub better going forward.. But it didn't seem they did. And how much will it cost them in 2011?